2021 Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move?

Primal cat food

Primal is a pet food company known for making natural raw pet food products for both cats and dogs. They offer freeze-dried raw complete meals, raw frozen product, as well as treats, broths, and food toppers.

To help guide you in picking the best raw food for your cat, we created this Primal cat food reviews of their top-rated cat food products available on Chewy.com.

WHY 20,000+ READERS HAVE TRUSTED US FOR YEARS

Here at FelineLiving.Net we have a dedicated mission to provide cat owners like you with well-researched information so they can provide the best care and nutrition to their cat.

Our readers rely upon the cat food reviews, articles and recall alerts that we research and publish. We also routinely update and review our own reviews ensuring that any changes by manufacturers are brought to your attention.

FelineLiving.Net is maintained by Mary Nielsen & her staff. Mary is an animal lover of both cats and dogs. She and her staff are passionate about animals and work hard to provide you with a wealth of information for you and your cat.

Launched in 2001, Primal Pet Food was inspired by a dog named Luna. According to Primal’s website, founder Matt Koss’ dog Luna was displaying signs of renal failure.

At the advice of a holistic veterinarian, Matt switched Luna to a diet of raw food and bones known as BARF (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food). This type of diet mimics an animal’s diet in the wild.

Luna’s health dramatically improved, as did her energy levels. Inspired by the overall improvement in his dog’s health and happiness, Matt decided to bring his raw pet food products to the market so other pets can enjoy the same health benefits that Luna had.

According to their website, Primal aims to provide food products as close to nature as possible. The brand offers complete meals for cats and dogs, as well as treats, bone broths, meal toppers, raw frozen product, raw bones, and even raw goat milk.

Their website lists 4 lines of products for the complete meals: Starter Pack, Raw Frozen Formula, Raw Pronto Formula, and Freeze-dried Formula.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 1

You love what you see? Purrfect! Rest assured that I put these products on the list specifically due to their genuine quality and not for other reasons. I would just like to be transparent with you and inform you that FelineLiving may obtain a share of sales or other monetary compensation from the links on this page. I hope your furry friends will love these reviewed products and that it will spark joy in each pair of feline eyes!

Mary Nielsen ♥

Primal Cat Food Reviews

IMAGE PRODUCT  
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 2
Raw Freeze-dried Nuggets Feline Chicken & Salmon
  • Made with chicken meat and chicken organs along with real salmon
  • Freeze-dried form that’s fast and easy to serve
  • Crafted in the USA
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 3
Primal Turkey Formula Nuggets
  • Made with turkey meat and chicken organs, along with fresh ground bone
  • All the benefits of a raw ancestral diet
  • With certified organic minerals and unrefined vitamins
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 4
Primal Beef & Salmon Formula Nuggets
  • Made with beef organs and real salmon
  • Highly-palatable, freeze-dried form
  • Grain free
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 5
Primal Rabbit Formula Nuggets
  • Made with rabbit meat and organs
  • Highly-palatable treat
  • Freeze-dried form
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 6
Primal Pronto Chicken & Salmon Formula
  • Taurine supplement for optimum retinal health
  • Superior levels of amino and essential fatty acids
  • Made with fresh chicken & cold-water, wild-caught salmon
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 7
Primal Pronto Pork Formula
  • Zero syntethic vitamis
  • Manufactured in the USA
  • Made from ethically raised, fresh pork
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 8
Primal Pork Bone Broth
  • Provides vital moisture to your pet's diet
  • Gelatin aids the intestines and helps maintain a healthy gut
  • Organic turmeric serves as a natural anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and detoxifier
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 9
Primal Fresh Topper Omega Mussels
  • Rich in Omega-3 fatty acids, glucosamine, & chondroitin
  • Mussel meat has unique properties that support joint health
  • With organic turmeric & organic raw unfiltered apple cider vinegar
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 10
Primal Goat Milk+ Pumpkin Spice
  • Excellent source of moisture
  • Added pumpkin and ginger to support digestion
  • Blend of three beneficial microorganisms deliver 5 billion CFUs/oz
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 11
Primal Butcher’s Blend Lamb
  • Fresh lamb for superior levels of aminos
  • No gluten, synthethic vitamins and antibiotics
  • Finely ground, fresh lamb bones for a natural source of calcium
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 12
Primal Market Mix Chicken
  • Fresh chicken is #1 ingredient
  • Certified organic produce for antioxidants and phytonutrients
  • Finely ground, fresh chicken bones for a natural source of calcium
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 13
Primal Turkey Liver Munchies
  • Wholesome treats for both dogs and cats
  • Crunchy and have an irresistible flavor
  • Made from single source protein and with no salt or preservatives
VIEW LATEST PRICE →
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 14
Primal Organic Chicken Nibs Jerky Treats
  • From single-source proteins
  • Perfect for those with food allergies
  • Treats are produced using USDA organic chicken
VIEW LATEST PRICE →

Reviewed Primal Products

  1. Primal Raw Freeze-dried Nuggets Feline Chicken & Salmon
  2. Primal Turkey Formula Nuggets
  3. Primal Beef & Salmon Formula Nuggets
  4. Primal Rabbit Formula Nuggets
  5. Primal Pronto Chicken & Salmon Formula
  6. Primal Pronto Pork Formula
  7. Primal Pork Bone Broth
  8. Primal Fresh Topper Omega Mussels
  9. Primal Goat Milk+ Pumpkin Spice
  10. Primal Butcher’s Blend Lamb
  11. Primal Market Mix Chicken
  12. Primal Turkey Liver Munchies
  13. Primal Organic Chicken Nibs Jerky Treats

Freeze Dried Food Products

Nuggets

Primal’s Freeze-Dried Nuggets is a line of shelf-stable and ready-to-serve cat food that you could portion, shred, and rehydrate with water or broth. 

Primal Chicken & Salmon Formula Nuggets

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 15
Offers your hungry kitty all the benefits of a safe and wholesome raw-food diet—without you having to grind, chop, measure or mix the ingredients yourself!

Primal’s Raw Freeze-dried Nuggets offer all the health benefits of raw, natural food with the convenience of dry food. No need to grind, chop, and mix the raw ingredients.

These raw freeze-dried products are recommended for cats of all life stages. It can be served dry just like dry kibble, or mixed with a little water to rehydrate.

This fresh chicken and wild-caught salmon cat food is high in protein, amino, and essential fatty acids. The first of its ingredients is chicken. Finely ground chicken bones are added for a natural source of calcium.

It is rich in vitamins and minerals from organic produce such as kale, squash, carrots, and other fruits and vegetables. Vitamin E (possibly mixed tocopherols) is also included to help support immune system health.

The first five ingredients of this freeze-dried cat food are chicken, chicken necks, chicken gizzards, salmon, and chicken livers.

Pros

Helps with weight control. As the Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Chicken & Salmon Formula is high in protein, Cats do not need to gorge on food to satisfy their hunger. As a result, the cats do not overeat when served with this product. They are fuller for longer and seem satisfied until their next meal. Some chonky cats have lost their excess weights since being fed this chicken and salmon recipe.

More active kitties. According to reviews on Chewy’s website, numerous cat owners have noticed an increase in their cat’s energy levels. They have been more active and playful since switching to this Primal freeze-dried chicken & salmon cat food. Many take this as a sign of good overall health.

primal cat food reviews

Cons

Fruits and veggies. This raw freeze-dried cat food is high in protein from chicken, chicken gizzard and liver, as well as salmon. However, it does contain plant-based ingredients such as organic kale, blueberries, squash, carrots, cranberries, and other produce.

A few cat parents feel that having the said amount of plant-based ingredients defeats the purpose of a raw diet that is supposed to mimic prey food. According to such reviews, plant-based ingredients offer no nutritional value to cats.

Conclusion

Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Chicken & Salmon Formula is a high quality grain-free raw food that cats seem to thrive on. They are able to maintain healthy weights and do not overeat. The cats have shown an increase in their energy and activity levels.

However, some feel that the plant-based ingredients in this food diminish its quality, as far as health benefits are concerned. Plant products however, are usually present in preys’ stomachs.

This places the vegetables and fruits in a cat’s natural diet. Plant-based ingredients are rich in fiber, vitamins, and minerals that cats also benefit from.

Primal Turkey Formula Nuggets

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 16
Made with antibiotic, hormone and steroid-free turkey meat and chicken organs, along with fresh ground bone for calcium supplementation.

Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Turkey Formula has fresh turkey meat as the first of its ingredients for high quality protein. This can also be served as dry food, or with some water for a rehydrated wet food.

Finely ground fresh turkey bones are included in this product for optimum levels of calcium. Sardine oil is added for omega 3 fatty acids. Other healthy ingredients of this freeze-dried raw cat food are organic apple cider vinegar, organic celery, and organic coconut oil among others.

This turkey recipe’s first five ingredients are turkey, turkey necks, turkey hearts or turkey gizzards, turkey livers, and organic collard greens.

Pros

Healthy skin and coat. Numerous cat parents have noticed significant improvements in their cats’ skin and fur quality. Their fur are softer and shinier since the cats were given Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Turkey Formula regularly.

Shedding has stopped for some cats who were previously losing clumps of their fur.

Good for sensitive tummies. Cats with sensitive stomachs have been able to keep this turkey recipe down without upsetting their tummies. This cat food contains no grains, gluten, corn, soy, or wheat. It even has no peas.

Ingredients such as grains and corn commonly found in cat food products could sometimes trigger food sensitivities. No more vomiting or diarrhea for these kitties.

primal cat food reviews

Cons

Possible recipe change. According to a few reviews on Chewy’s website, the turkey recipe cat food seems to have changed from what they used to get. The nuggets appear to be tougher than before. A few cat fans of this turkey recipe seem to prefer the old formula than the new one.

Conclusion

Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Turkey Formula has given numerous cats soft, glossy coats. Not only have their skin and fur improved, cats with sensitive stomachs have also thrived on this raw turkey recipe.

They are able to keep this cat food down, and vomiting and other symptoms have been reduced or completely eliminated.

A few fans of this turkey formula have noticed some changes in the recipe. Their cats are not fans of this new formulation.

Primal Beef & Salmon Formula Nuggets

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 17
Sourced with only the best ingredients, including a steroid-free beef organs and real salmon, this tasty and nutritious diet is packed with naturally derived vitamins and minerals.

Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Beef & Salmon Formula is made of 91% real beef, salmon, organs, and bone. The first of this cat food’s ingredients is beef hearts.

It is rich in omega 3 fatty acids from cold-water wild-caught salmon and salmon oil. Vitamin E is added as another source of antioxidants. This cat food also includes taurine for retinal health.

The first five ingredients of this beef and salmon product are beef hearts, beef livers, ground beef bones, salmon, and organic kale.

Pros

Beautiful, shiny coats. Many kitties who eat Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Beef & Salmon Formula regularly have grown healthy, shiny coats and their owners could not be prouder. Their fur are soft, silky, and shinier than before. Salmon oil and cod liver oil gives additional omega fatty acids that help promote healthy skin and coats.

Cats love it! This beef and salmon cat food is a hit among cats. It is rich and tasty with beef hearts and liver, and cold-water wild-caught salmon. These ingredients make this food not only tasty, but also high in protein.

primal cat food reviews

Cons

Hard to crumble. A few cat owners find this particular recipe quite hard to crumble compared to other freeze dried cat food from the brand. This beef and salmon cat food takes a bit longer to rehydrate compared to other variants.

Conclusion

Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Beef & Salmon Formula offers a complete and balanced rich-tasting meal for kitties. Cat owners have noticed significant improvements in their cats’ skin and coats. Their fur are softer and shinier than before. Even cats who previously had itchy, flaky skin have found relief since being switched to this raw food.

A few buyers however, find this beef and salmon variant much tougher to crumble compared to other Primal variants. It also takes longer to rehydrate.

Primal Rabbit Formula Nuggets

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 18
A tasty and nutritious diet packed with steroid-free rabbit meat and organs, along with fresh ground bone for calcium supplementation. It's also an excellent way to maintain a proper weight and boost overall health.

Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Rabbit Formula’s ingredients is made of 93% rabbit, organs, and bone. Only 7% of this freeze-dried product is made of produce and supplements.

The first of its ingredients is rabbit. This freeze-dried raw cat food is perfect for cats with allergies to grains, chicken, fish, and any other proteins. As rabbit is the only animal protein source, it is highly recommended for cats with dietary restrictions.

It contains produce such as organic celery, cranberries, pumpkin seeds, collard greens, and even apple cider vinegar as sources of antioxidants, vitamins and minerals.

The first five ingredients of this rabbit cat food are rabbit (with ground bone), rabbit livers, rabbit hearts, organic collard greens, and organic squash.

Pros

Good for sensitive tummies. Cats who were previously suffering from digestive issues such as diarrhea, vomiting, and upset stomachs are doing quite well on this Primal freeze-dried rabbit recipe. They are able to keep this food down, and other symptoms have also improved.

Goodbye allergies. Kitties with skin allergies have also thrived on the Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Rabbit Formula. Their flaky skin and scabs have been reduced or have completely cleared up. Hair have started to grow on bald patches. Their coats are much softer and shinier.

primal cat food reviews

Cons

Hard nuggets. According to a handful of reviews, the nuggets are a bit too tough for some cat owners. They are hard to crumble and take a long time to rehydrate.

Conclusion

If you have a cat with food sensitivities such as allergies to fish, poultry, or grains, Primal Pet Foods Raw Freeze-Dried Feline Rabbit Formula may be the one for her. Many cats with sensitive tummies and food allergies have thrived well on this freeze-dried raw rabbit recipe.

They were able to keep the food down, and those who had skin allergies now have much healthier skin and coat.

However, some find the nuggets too hard and too large to break down into small pieces. A few also find that it takes too long to rehydrate.

Pronto

The raw frozen Pronto line comes in bite-sized and easy-to-portion format. The recipes here all thaw in minutes.

Primal Pronto Chicken & Salmon Formula

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 19
A recipe that starts with fresh chicken & cold-water, wild-caught salmon for superior levels of amino and essential fatty acids.

This Primal Pronto recipe features cold-water wild-caught salmon and cage-free raised chicken to provide your cat with optimum levels of amino (13 to be exact) and essential fatty acids (omega 3 and omega 6). 

The formula uses only USDA organic produce and no synthetic vitamins. Only naturally-sourced ones are provided. 

The first five ingredients of the recipe are chicken (with ground bone), chicken livers, salmon, organic pumpkin seeds, and organic sunflower seeds.

Pros

Low calorie. One cup of this raw food only contains 140 kcal per cup. 

Meaty. The first three ingredients are all high-quality meat proteins. It excellently combines muscle meat with organs and calcium-rich bones.

Premium ingredients. There are no fillers included. It’s all meat, produce, healthy oils, or supplements.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 20

Cons

Not easy to find. The recipes are not sold in many pet stores and can be hard to find.

Conclusion

This Primal recipe is recommended for your furry feline friends. Not only is it highly meat-based, produce included are USDA organic so you are sure that it is quite safe for your pet. The bite-sized portions also make it easier for older or ill/recovering cats to eat.

We like how the brand lays out all the nutritional facts. Each vitamin, mineral, amino acid, and others are listed down with their precise value. It’s easy to note down exactly what your kitty is getting by just looking at their nutritional info list. 

The food also provides cats a safe way to eat bone (full of calcium and phosphorus) and organs (richer in nutrition than muscle meat) in a way that mimics a cat’s ancestral diet. The only problem we have with the food is that it is not commonly sold in most stores.

Primal Pronto Pork Formula

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 21
With fresh pork for superior levels of amino and essential fatty acids. Loaded with fruits and vegetables, this formulation will surely make your pet healthy and active.

Using pork as the main ingredient, this recipe is crafted to appeal to cat owners who have sensitive pets. While pork is not exactly a novel protein anymore (with the recent trend in utilizing it in pet food), it is still not as common as chicken or beef and is not associated with too many allergy reports.

Packed with organs and ground bones, this formulation seeks to make it even more nutritious for your feline. Several different products (all USDA organic) round off the recipe to make it more balanced.

The first five ingredients are pork hearts, ground pork bones, pork livers, organic celery, and organic squash.

Pros

Comes with several fruits and veggies. There are several fruits and vegetables included in the food to keep the recipe more holistic. The organic produce provides cats with plenty of naturally-sourced antioxidants.

Good amount of protein. Because it utilizes organs too, the protein content (13%) is at a good level for raw food. 

Nutrition for all life stages. This food provides a balanced nutrition for felines of all life stages.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 22

Cons

Not easily found in stores. Since the food needs to be frozen, not a lot of stores carry this recipe and others of its line. 

Conclusion

If you’re looking for quality cat food, then this raw recipe is one of the best we can recommend. The formulation is about as pure as you can get with its utilization of raw meat and fresh produce that undergo very little processing. 

The food is loaded with about 10 fruits/veggies and two types of fish oil. The produce provide a lot of the antioxidants, while the oils offer essential fatty acids that are great for maintaining the skin and coat of felines.

The frozen food, however, is not available in many stores. That is the only disadvantage it has, aside from perhaps its higher than average price. But premium food always come at non-cheap prices and are totally worth it.

Toppers & Hydration

Bone Broth

Broths offer a hydrating addition to any diet, from kibbles to wet canned food.

Primal Pork Bone Broth

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 23
A hydrating, wholesome addition to any diet—plus beneficial nutrients to support joint health, digestion, and liver health.

Primal’s Pork Bone Broth offers cats a more tempting way to hydrate. It’s common for many cats not to drink as much water as they need, which can lead to dehydration.

The broth is a good way to deliver moisture while also providing felines with a little more flavor and nutrition on top of their regular food.

This broth comes with an herb — turmeric — to aid your cat’s digestion and serve as an anti-inflammatory, antioxidant, and detoxifier.

The first five ingredients of this recipe are pork bone broth (filtered water and pork bones), organic carrots, organic butternut squash, organic apple cider vinegar, and organic celery.

Pros

Easy pour. The broth comes in an easy pour package that you can reseal after use.

Suitable for cats and dogs. If you have a multi-pet household, this bone broth makes it easy to feed all of your pets a nourishing and hydrating meal.

Ethical and organic. The pork used was raised ethically and crate-free, while the produce are all USDA organic.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 24

Cons

Not widely available. The pork bone broth is not widely available, even in online stores. You might need to stock up if you chance upon it.

Conclusion

This Primal broth provides your kitty with the vital moisture that he needs in a sneaky and tempting way. The broth not only adds hydration to a diet, but it can help raise the palatability profile of a food and make it more enticing to picky eaters. 

It also helps that the ingredients are all premium quality. It’s not just a simple broth, because it contains a lot of nutritious and whole ingredients that are designed to support a healthy gut, joints, and liver. It’s not as widely available as some other well-known brands, but it should be.

Fresh Topper

Fresh Toppers feature specialized and functional ingredients that are directed towards supporting a cat’s digestive, joint, and immune health.

Primal Fresh Topper Omega Mussels

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 25
Aromatic whole-food toppers with specialized, functional ingredients—targeted towards digestion, immunity, or joint health!

This Primal Fresh Topper formulation employs a mélange of mussels to support your cat’s joint health. Mussel meat is known for its glucosamine, chondroitin, and omega fatty acid content — enough to help keep your cat moving and more active every day.

Since the topper also contains bone broth, the collagen from the broth provides additional glucosamine and chondroitin. It also employs a raw and organic apple cider vinegar to support your feline buddy’s skeletal system.

The first five ingredients are steamed Chilean mussels, pork bone broth, organic chia seeds, organic extra virgin olive oil, and organic parsley. 

Pros

Contains no grains. The Omega Mussels is crafted for all cats, sensitive and non-sensitive alike. The absence of grains makes the topper ideal for felines who can’t take corn, grain, or wheat.

No legumes or lentils. While legumes are completely safe when taken in moderation, the lack of it in a cat food can also bring a bit of peace of mind to the cat owners, especially when it has been linked to DCM.

Completely balanced. The topper doesn't just focus on mussels, but it also includes a good helping of produce to make it more holistic.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 26

Cons

Frozen. Being sold frozen is not really a point against the product, but it does make it more difficult to source it online. As of now, not a lot of stores stock Primal’s Fresh Topper. 

Conclusion

It may be a little difficult to find, but when you do, stock up since this topper is a great help for cats who need more support for ailing joints. It acts as both a supplemental nutrition and as something that you can use to entice finicky kitties to eat up their regular dish. 

The topper is supportive of sensitive and non-sensitive cats alike, since it doesn’t contain any of the common allergy triggers such as corn, soy, or wheat. All of the produce ingredients are USDA organic, and there are no synthetic vitamins included.

It’s also good that the food can keep for a long time. Just get what you need and thaw, and put the rest back insize the freezer since the container is resealable.

Raw Goat Milk

Raw Goat Milk offers cats a nutrient-rich option for hydration that’s so much better than water. It’s packed with vitamins, minerals, and electrolytes.

Primal Goat Milk+ Pumpkin Spice

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 27
A nutrient-rich hydration option plus organic pumpkin and ginger—ingredients that are known to provide fiber and support digestion!

Raw goat milk makes a perfect supplement for cats who suffer from various kinds of allergies. It has anti-inflammatory properties that can help soothe itchy skin or upset tummies. 

The recipe is also crafted with beneficial organisms to keep the digestive system as healthy as possible.

The first five ingredients are raw goat milk, organic pumpkin, dried lactobacillus lactis fermentation product, dried Lactobacillus acidophilus fermentation product, and dried Enterococcus faecium fermentation product.

Pros

Contains beneficial organisms. There are three types of beneficial organisms in this raw goat milk, enough to deliver 5 billion CFUs per ounce.

Aids digestion. Apart from the live organisms, the raw milk also contains pumpkin for a healthy dose of fiber. 

Long shelf life. The raw goat milk is placed in resealable bottles that you can store in the fridge for up to 10 days. It keeps even longer when stored in the freezer.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 28

Cons

Not every cat likes it. The milk may be tempting to many felines, but the hint of spice can turn off some kitties who are not used to the additional spicy flavor. 

Conclusion

Primal’s Raw Goat Milk in Pumpkin Spice offers kitty cats an interesting hydrating twist to their regular meals. Milk appeals to a lot of felines, and this particular kind contains less lactose than cow’s milk and is more tolerated by most. Although, some cats may not like the hint of spice that  comes along with it.

The milk is easily digestible, and when you figure in the live beneficial microorganisms and fiber content, you have a formula that’s excellent for supporting a cat’s digestive health. 

This milk also lasts a long time. Stored in the fridge, it’s good for up to 10 days. But store it in the freezer, and it will stay good for as long as one year.

Butcher’s Blend

This is a line featuring easy-thaw raw meat toppers made from high-quality protein.

Primal Butcher’s Blend Lamb

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 29
A quick-thaw, raw meat topper made from only high-quality animal protein for a boost of fresh food nutrition.

Butcher’s Blend Lamb by Primal gives regular kibbles or wet food a big protein boost. It features fresh and raw lamb as a topper to give your kitty more of the essential amino and fatty acids he deserves.

Utilizing bone and organs, this recipe raises the nutrition level even further. 

There are only three ingredients in the recipe — lamb heart, lamb bone, and lamb liver.

Pros

All meat and bone. There are only three ingredients in this raw formulation, and they are all either meat or healthy lamb bone.

Ethically-raised lamb. Primal uses only ethically-raised lamb that were not given antibiotic shots for a truly healthy food for your pet.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 30

Cons

Not widely available. Understandably, the food needs freezing since it is made of raw ingredients. However, that makes it a little more inaccessible to a lot of parents since not many stores stock this up.

Conclusion

If you’re worried about the protein content your cat is getting or wish to provide him with more, this Butcher’s Blend formula is the right choice.

It carries a minimum 13% crude protein content. But that’s not all. It has omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, four kinds of vitamins, 10 minerals, and the all-important taurine.

The lamb used is also ethically-raised and without the use of growth-promoting antibiotics. Sensitive kitties will also thrive on this recipe since it does not contain gluten.

It’s just pure meat and bones with no synthetic vitamins added either. 

Market Mix Raw Toppers

The Market Mix Raw Toppers range also features high-quality proteins but combines those with premium organic produce.

Primal Market Mix Chicken

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 31
A raw meat topper made from fresh chicken and a finely ground chicken bones for a natural source of calcium.

Market Mix Raw Toppers are similar to Primal’s Butcher Line with one exception — it has certified organic produce too. The raw topper offers a bit more nutrition for kitty cats who may need supplemental feeding. 

This recipe’s main ingredient is fresh chicken that has been raised cage-free and without the use of antibiotics.

The first five ingredients of this recipe are chicken, chicken neck, chicken heart, chicken liver, and organic kale. 

Pros

Naturally-sourced calcium. The recipe utilizes finely ground and fresh chicken bones to provide your feline with the necessary calcium he needs for stronger bones.

Uses organ meats. Muscle meat is healthy but organs contain a lot more nutrients. 

Low on calories. Despite the addition of organ meat, the calorie remains low at only 29/kcal per ounce. 

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 32

Cons

A little expensive. Not really a full ‘con,’ though. The price is higher compared to other toppers, but it is understandable given that it’s fully made from real meat, vegetables, and fruits. There are no flour or other ingredients that may be considered as fillers. 

Conclusion

Felines can’t resist the draw of real meat, especially organ meats like liver. With this recipe, you can supplement their diet with a load of protein and sneak in those veggies and fruits that many usually turn their nose up on.

This formulation contains 11 minerals, 4 vitamins, an essential amino acid for cats (taurine), and two types of omega fatty acids (omega-3 and omega-6), aside from the all-important protein, fat, and fiber. 

It’s priced higher than some brands, but you can see directly from the label that this topper’s value is worth it.

Munchies

These are crunchy foods that are ideal as either rewards or training treats.

Primal Turkey Liver Munchies

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 33
As a single source protein, Turkey Liver Munchies offer a healthy snack for cats and a nutritious training and obedience reward for dogs.

Primal Treats Freeze-dried Turkey Liver Munchies are healthy, natural treats for both cats and dogs. This single-source protein product is made from turkey raised in the US without antibiotics or added hormones. This crunchy turkey liver treat is perfect for cats with allergies as this contains no other ingredients. It is as clean as a treat can get.

Pros

A hit with the kitties! Cats go crazy for Primal Treats Freeze-dried Turkey Liver Munchies. They love the rich taste and the crunchy texture of the freeze-dried turkey liver.

Big pieces. The big liver pieces make the bag of treats last longer for kitties. Each piece can be broken into smaller bite-sized pieces for cats.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 34

Cons

Too big pieces. Some find the pieces of this product too big for their cats. As this treat is also meant for dogs, the pieces are bigger than your average cat treat. However, the big pieces are appreciated by others mainly because they get more cat treats by breaking them into pieces.

Conclusion

Primal Treats Freeze-dried Turkey Liver Munchies are crunchy, tasty treats that you can give to both your cats and dogs. Made of only turkey liver, it has no fillers or artificial enhancers. These treats are perfect for cats with food sensitivities. The taste is quite popular with cats too.

However, some find the pieces too big for their kitties. Many find that the big pieces mean more treats per bag, as they break them into smaller pieces that are just right for their cats.

Primal Organic Chicken Nibs Jerky Treats

Primal Treats Freeze-dried Chicken Nibs are moist pieces of chicken goodness. It has no grains, gluten, corn, soy, or artificial enhancers such as colors, flavors, and preservatives. The first of its ingredients is certified organic chicken. This is a truly healthy treat that your cats will enjoy.

WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 35
A treat made from pieces of moist chicken without the addition of grains, gluten, corn, soy, or artificial enhancers. A truly healthy treat that your cats will enjoy.

This product’s only ingredients are organic chicken, organic blackstrap molasses (unsulphered), and sea salt.

Pros

Just the right size. Primal Treats Freeze-dried Chicken Nibs are perfectly bite-sized. They are great for training your cats. No need to break big pieces into smaller ones. Simply take out of the bag and serve.

Great for weight management. Cats who needed to shed some excess weight could benefit from these moist morsels. These chicken treats from Primal are high in protein from certified organic chicken. There are no fillers from grains, soy, corn, or other produce like potatoes or peas. You can be confident that these treats will not add to your cat’s waistline.

Primal Organic Chicken Nibs Jerky Treats

Cons

Short shelf life. Some cat owners find the treats’ shelf life of 14 days in the fridge too short. The treats come in 4 oz bags, and some owners, especially those who own one cat are not able to give all the treats within the 14-day shelf life.

Conclusion

Primal Treats Freeze-dried Chicken Nibs are quite a hit with cats. It is tasty and convenient to serve. The treats come in small pieces that can be great as training treats. No need to break up big pieces into bite-sized ones.

As it is high in protein, it has been great for cats who are trying to maintain healthy weights. The shelf life however is quite short. It can be stored in the fridge up to 14 days from opening.

What Primal Cat Food Offers

Primal’s cat foods are divided into different ranges. We’ve only touched on a few, but all of its offerings are listed down here.

Balanced Bases

The Balanced Bases consists of cat food ranges that are crafted to be complete meals.

Raw Frozen Pronto Formulas

  • Chicken & Salmon 
  • Pork
  • Rabbit
  • Turkey

Freeze-Dried Nuggets

  • Beef & Salmon
  • Chicken & Salmon
  • Duck
  • Pork

Raw Frozen Nuggets

  • Beef & Salmon
  • Chicken & Salmon
  • Duck
  • Pork

Toppers & Hydrators

These cat food lines feature supplemental nutrition in the form of meat or hydration.

Bone Broth:

  • Chicken
  • Pork
  • Turkey
  • Beef

Edible Elixirs/Fresh Toppers

  • Omega Mussels
  • Awesome Squash
  • Power Greens

Raw Goat Milk

  • Original
  • Green Goodness
  • Pumpkin Spice
  • Cranberry Blast
primal cat food review

Butcher’s Blend Raw Toppers

  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • Lamb
  • Pork

Market Mix Raw Toppers

  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • Lamb
  • Pork

Treats & Chews

These lines feature high-quality snacks for your good feline.

Munchies

  • Freeze-Fried Beef Liver
  • Freeze-Dried Pork Liver
  • Freeze-Dried Turkey Liver

Raw Recreational Bones

  • Beef Marrow

Raw Meaty Bones

  • Chicken Neck

Summary

Primal is popular among cat owners who have switched their cat to a diet that is closer to what nature intended. The brand offers products such as freeze-dried raw meals and raw frozen products.

Its freeze-dried products can be served like dry food or with some water for wet food meals. The brand has many protein options, and you can be sure to find at least one suitable for your cat – even for one who has special dietary requirements.

The ingredients in Primal’s cat food are all high quality freeze-dried raw meat, such as chicken, rabbit, beef, quail, duck, venison, and pork that are raised ethically and without antibiotics or added hormones.

The company also uses cold-water wild-caught salmon. All of its complete cat food lines are free from grains, wheat, soy, corn, and potatoes.

The plant-based ingredients are highly-nutritious, such as organic celery, kale, cranberries, blueberries, carrots, spinach, and many others.

These are the sources of vitamins and minerals instead of synthetic supplements. However, Primal does include vitamin E supplement (likely mixed tocopherols) in some of their products.

approved by pets

The brand does not use artificial enhancers such as flavors, colors, or preservatives. Ingredients with known multiple health benefits, such as apple cider vinegar and organic coconut oil, are also included in its Primal Nuggets products.

The cat foods have received great reviews regarding the health benefits they give to numerous cats. From healthier skin and coats, to regulated weights, to higher energy levels. Many pets seem to thrive on Primal’s cat foods, especially those with food sensitivities.

The single-source protein options have been great for cats who have food allergies or sensitive stomachs. Cats who suffer from allergy symptoms, such as skin problems, diarrhea, and vomiting have been given relief by being put on a Primal Pet Food diet. Their conditions have significantly improved or were completely resolved.

However, just like other raw foods, Primal’s cat foods tend to have a higher phosphorus content. This is not recommended for a cat with kidney disease, as they require food with a much lower phosphorus content.

Due to the high-quality ingredients, Primal products cost more than your average cat food. The foods do, however, save you time and effort in preparing a wholesome raw meal for your cats.

Based on ingredient quality, results delivered, reviews from cat parents, and cost, Primal is a good brand of cat food if you wish to switch your cat to a raw food diet. The brand offers a variety of choices even to those who have food restrictions.

The meals are convenient and easy to serve and have delivered good results to numerous cats. As these products are raw, Primal says to make sure that all work surfaces, hands, and bowls be washed with hot, soapy water after handling freeze-dried raw meat products.

[year] Primal Cat Food Reviews: Is Feeding Raw the Best Move? 36

Have Primal cat foods ever been recalled?

Yes. In 2011, some of the chicken & salmon cat food formula have been recalled due to possible salmonella contamination. In 2015, a limited quantity of Primal’s raw frozen cat food products were recalled due to potentially low thiamine levels. Two years later, a recall of a few varieties of freeze-dried dog and cat food was issued due to not-so-ideal bone grind size.

Is primal cat food good?

Primal Raw Cat Food is a frozen diet made by Primal Pet Foods out of California. This cat food review is as unbiased as possible and is aided by our years of experience feeding Primal to our own animals and feedback from our customers. The Good. Formulated with 100% human-grade ingredients.

Where is primal pet food made?

Products are manufactured in the USA. Specifically, All of their Mixes, Grinds, Treats, Raw Meaty and Recreational Bones are manufactured at their headquarters in Fairfield, CA.

Which is better primal or Stella and Chewy?

Primal Dog Food is generally better than Stella and Chewy's in terms of nutrition because it contains higher amounts of protein and fat.

  • Updated May 25, 2021
Mary Nielsen
 

A huge animal lover, born and raised around dogs, cats, chickens... Self-educated pet care nerd. Currently parent of three adopted cats and one small mutt. Animal adoption advocate. Loves a good book (about animals) and playing the piano.