10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty

Updated on:
Some articles include affiliate links, and we may receive compensation when you make a purchase through these links.
10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 1

Our quick take: You can cook for your cat, but a homemade diet is only safe in the long run if it is complete and balanced. A 2019 UC Davis study published in JAVMA checked 94 home-made cat food recipes from websites, books and vets and found that none supplied every essential nutrient at recommended levels. If you want to feed homemade food every day, have a recipe made for your cat by a board-certified veterinary nutritionist. Cook meat thoroughly, add the supplements the recipe calls for (especially taurine and calcium), and treat the simple recipes below as occasional meals or toppers, not a full diet.

Perhaps you've gotten frustrated in searching for the perfect cat food. You might feel betrayed to find that the pricey gourmet cat food that advertised itself as being good for health and all natural is little better than spicy wood pulp.

Not only do you have to find a cat food that's nutritionally sound and in your budget, but it has to be something your furry but finicky friend will eat.

It could be you're ready to throw up your hands and say “Forget it! I'll cook my cat's food myself!” “I'll go for homemade cat food!”  This is really not a bad idea, provided you know what you're doing.

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 2

Why Should You Make Your Own Homemade Cat Food?

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 3

For starters, you will know exactly what's in your cat's food because you put it there yourself. Dry kibble tends to be loaded with carbohydrates and plant based proteins.

Commercial food is not risk-free either: recalls for Salmonella, mold toxins (mycotoxins) and nutrient errors do happen. You want better nutrition for your cat.

Dry food also does not have a high enough moisture content for cats. Many people remember the mass pet food recalls in 2007 after many unfortunate animals experienced renal failure after eating contaminated food. If you cook your cat's food yourself, you will know exactly what she's eating and, almost as importantly, what she's not eating.

Now let's talk about costs. Will it be cheaper in the long run to cook your own cat food? That all depends. Are you using chicken or rabbit? Unless you own a warren, chicken will usually be cheaper.

Are you getting your ingredients from Whole Foods, a typical grocery store or the farmer's market? Do you want to use supplements? Just how much does your cat eat? How much should your cat be eating? Do you prefer organic? Will you be willing to do your own prep work? All cats are different.

When considering how much your food bill will be for your cat, it's a good idea to weigh it against a possible vet bill. Cats that eat healthy have better health and won't need to see a vet as often. Plus, healthy cats are happy cats.

While cats are partial to routine, they do like some variety in their diet. Making your cats something new every few days is much better than giving them the same food day after day, only for them to turn their noses up at it out of boredom.


But what if…you don't know how to cook?

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 4

In case, you are no kitchen genie, fret not! We recommend to you The Honest Kitchen easy homemade food.

This brand offers a wide assortment of wet, dry, and dehydrated products for pets—complete and balanced meals made with wholesome ingredients and slowly cooked over low temperatures to remove moisture, thus preserving more of the nutritional integrity of the raw ingredients.

The team is made up of loving pet parents, animal nutritionists, veterinarians, and other animal lovers who all want the best for their pets and for yours.

This company produces healthy pet food recipes that deliver real, noticeable results including higher energy levels, silkier coat and skin, improved digestion, and a healthy body weight. (I should know. Some of the brand’s products are on my pet food rotation!) 

Your cat’s diet on Honest Kitchen’s products will be just as good as your own (or better), because these are made from human-grade ingredients.

PROS

  • Exceeds AAFCO quality standards
  • USFDA registered
  • Made from human-grade ingredients
  • Easy to prepare (just add water)
  • Highly palatable, even picky eaters can't resist
  • Comes in dehydrated, wet and dry recipes for cats
  • No weird/funky odor
  • Easy to store

CONS

  • More expensive than traditional pet food
  • Can be a little messy at times
WHY YOU SHOULD BUY
10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 5
The ingredients used in Honest Kitchen products are all human-grade and non-GMO. They not only promise 100% human-grade ingredients, but also minimally processed whole foods, health benefits you can see, and uncompromising quality and nutrition.

Raw Cat Food or Cooked?

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 6

To quote a popular meme, “Why not both?” People who are against raw food are worried about parasites and bacteria. People who are against cooked food are concerned about the loss of nutrients in their cats diet. In this case, it's better to look at the positive benefits each side has, use a little common sense and compromise. Consider par-cooking, heating it just enough to kill bacteria on the surface. Be aware that this does not make the inside of the meat safe, and ground meat has surface bacteria mixed all the way through, so it needs to be cooked through. The AVMA and the FDA advise against feeding cats raw or undercooked meat, and since late 2024 several raw cat foods in the US have been recalled after cats caught H5N1 bird flu. Read our raw diet for cats guide before choosing raw.

Use the same food safety precautions you would for preparing raw meat for human consumption. Do not cross-contaminate by using cutting boards and utensils used for raw meat on vegetables, store the meat at 40 degrees Fahrenheit or below and above all, wash your hands. Ground meat has surface bacteria mixed all the way through, so grinding it yourself does not make it safe to serve raw: cook ground meat through.

Keep in mind, your cat has different nutritional needs than yours. She can eat not only raw meat, but the organs that you might find disgusting. However, older pets being transitioned to homemade food diet and cats with sensitive or damaged gastrointestinal tracts might benefit more from a cooked food diet.

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 7

If you cook meat for your cat, cook it through (poultry to 165°F and ground meat to 160°F, the USDA safe temperatures) and keep the juices: taurine leaches into the cooking liquid, so add the broth back or use a taurine supplement. Rare meat can still carry Salmonella and other bacteria, and cats don't need the “enzymes” in raw meat, because they make their own digestive enzymes.

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 8

Avoid sausage meat and other manufactured meat as they contain sulfite preservatives that are not good for cats. In any case, consult a veterinarian before feeding your cat anything out of the ordinary for her.

The one place where raw versus cooked comes down to one or the other is when bones are involved. If your cat gnaws on bones, they should be raw rather than cooked as cooked bones can splinter and hurt your cat. Even then, supervise your cat's gnawing and remember that more than one or two a week in your cats diet can lead to constipation.

The essential nutrients needed in cats' diet:

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 9

Animal Protein

The cat is an obligate carnivore. Cats needs meat in their food to survive. Some cat foods will try to tout themselves as “high protein” only for it to be later revealed that the protein sources were soy, nuts, lentils or wheat gluten. This will not do. Cats can digest some plant protein, but they need nutrients found naturally only in animal tissue, such as taurine, arachidonic acid and ready-made vitamin A.

The domestic cat has a short digestive tract built for meat and a high need for protein, which is why animal protein should make up most of a homemade diet.

Animal Fats

You might want to cut down on fat but your cat doesn't! Cats needs easily digestible fats in their diet for energy. Specifically, cats need omega-6 fatty acids such as linolic and arachidonic acid. Fish oil, krill oil and flaxseed are all good sources of omega-3 fatty acids but you can also use poultry, beef and pork to get that healthy animal protein as well. If your cat has pancreatitis, you may want to feed her something lower in fat.

Calcium and phosphorus

Calcium and phosphorus are necessary for strong bones and teeth and is needed in your cats diet. Calcium is also needed to help blood clot and phosphorus boosts the reparation of cells. Phosphorus will help your cat metabolize protein and calcium helps those lightning quick muscles work. Small fishes like sardines and anchovies are calcium rich because their bones are tiny enough to be edible.

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 10

*Daily Recommended Allowance = DRA

While phosphorus can be found in nuts and beans, your cat will get more out of fish and poultry in their diet.

Taurine

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 8

This is a crucial amino acid that your cat cannot create for herself and must get it from the food she eats. Natural sources are lamb, beef, eggs, shellfish, cold water fish, brewer's yeast and dark chicken meat. Boiling meat can destroy the taurine present. Cats that do not eat enough taurine have vision and heart problems along with a general failure to thrive.

It is available as a nutritional supplement. The powdered form may be easiest to cook with.

Water

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 12

Cats don't usually drink as much water as they should. Their wild ancestors lived in dry climates and they got most of their needed moisture from prey. Because of this, a modern cat has little instinct to drink water. What's more, cats can be picky about what kind of water they drink. Feed your cats food that's good and moist to make sure she's staying hydrated.

Cats may like their food mixed in with a little meat based broth (preferably no salt added) to make it more succulent.

Vitamins

Your cat needs her nutrition and would be better off getting them from food sources than supplements in their diet. Cats can't convert beta-carotene from plant sources into vitamin A, so it needs to come from an animal source such as halibut, liver and kidneys. Beef liver is also a good source of vitamin D as are tuna, mackerel and salmon in your cats diet.

To help your cat have a healthy coat, vitamin E can be found in eggs. The B vitamins are essential to a cat's well being and can be found in liver, brown rice, poultry, fish and red meat.

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 13

Ingredients to avoid in your cats diet

This is no time to get experimental. You might like a little pep from onions and garlic, but your cat certainly will not. Onions and garlic are a big no-no to a cat's diet! Raw egg whites might have looked like they were good for Rocky Balboa, but they're not for your cat. Cook eggs fully: raw egg white contains avidin, which blocks the B vitamin biotin, and raw eggs can carry Salmonella.

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 8

Green tomatoes and tomato plants, grapes, raisins and anything made with them should not be given to your cat in her diet. Chocolate is a big NO as is anything with caffeine. Adult cats can't process most dairy products. Keep the sherry in the cabinet. Your cat can't taste sweets and sugar isn't good for your cats health anyway. See our full list of foods that are toxic to cats.

The essential ingredients For Homemade food

Meat

10 Homemade Cat Food Recipes That are Best and Healthy for your Kitty 15

It's at the top of the list for a good reason. Your cat is a carnivore, so her food should be almost entirely meat based. Whether you feed your cat raw meat or cooked meat, do be sure to follow safe handling protocol. It should be either rather hot or rather cold and for everyone's health, wash your hands.

Meat Types and Sources

Beef, pork, rabbit and fish are all good sources of animal protein for cats. Organ meats like liver are full of vitamin A. If you cave a hunter in the family who wants to give your cat a little venison, only let them eat muscle meat that's been fully cooked. While cats like tuna, c