Cat Myths Debunked [Top 20] – Do They Really Have Nine Lives?

Updated on:
Some articles include affiliate links, and we may receive compensation when you make a purchase through these links.
word myths on colorful wooden cubes

Every Halloween brings out the witches and their black cats, but cat folklore sticks around all year.

Our quick take: most popular cat “facts” are half true at best. Cats usually, but not always, land on their feet, and falls from a height still injure them. They don't have nine lives, can't see in total darkness, aren't truly nocturnal and don't need milk (most adult cats are lactose intolerant). A purr doesn't always mean a happy cat, eating grass doesn't usually mean a sick one, and pregnant women don't have to give up their cats. Below we sort 20 common cat myths into fact and fiction.

Let's take a moment to separate fact from fiction so that we can better understand our feline friends.

Cats Always Land on Their Feet

cat in a jump on a white background

“When you land on your head, do you land on your feet?” is a question posed in the Andrew Lloyd Webber musical Cats. There's also the famous buttered cat paradox. If you butter a cat's back and drop it, which end will it land on? (More on buttering cats later and why you shouldn't.)  

It's assumed that cats always land on their feet. Most of the time they do, but not always, and landing on their feet doesn't mean they walk away unhurt. Cats do have a “righting reflex“ that helps them orient themselves while falling.

If the fall is high enough that they have time to, a falling cat may spread their legs outward to create drag and are sometimes able to survive a fall that would likely kill a human. (Though Kitty won't be completely unscathed.)

Overweight cats, elderly cats and cats with ear problems have trouble with their righting reflex. Prevent your cat from falling out of windows by installing window guards or sturdy screens. Vets see so many cats hurt in falls from windows and balconies that the injuries have a name, “high-rise syndrome”: broken jaws and teeth, chest injuries and broken legs are typical. Any cat that falls from a height should see a vet, even if it seems fine.

Cats Have Nine Lives

British cat is celebrating a halloween and wearing a suit of vampire.

Nobody knows exactly where the saying started (in Spanish-speaking countries, cats are said to have seven lives). One popular theory goes back to Ancient Egypt, where cats were seen as practically divine. The Ancient Egyptian pantheon consisted of nine major gods and goddesses.  In many occidental societies, three is considered a magical number. Three cubed is nine.

The finely honed natural reflexes of cats mean they have a tendency to survive incidents that would kill other creatures. What numbers are considered magical or lucky differs by culture. If something were true, it would be true no matter the culture.

Therefore, “lucky” numbers are a myth. As for reincarnation, there is no scientific basis for this idea. It is not luck but evolution that makes a cat able to survive dangerous situations. There is no set number of how many disasters a cat can live through. For more on where the saying comes from, see do cats have 9 lives?

Black cats are unlucky

Black cat with yellow eyes isolated on a whit background

Once again, this is something based solely in cultural perception. For the longest time, black cats were associated with devils and witchcraft.

Many pagan gods were said to have the ability to shape shift into cats. In England, it's believed that if a woman has a black cat she will have many suitors. (A hint that such a woman was bewitching in more than one way?) In Scotland, being visited by a black cat is lucky.

In many places, it's unlucky if a black cat crosses your path but in Germany, it's only unlucky if going right to left and lucky if walking the other way. Sailors, anarchists and the Japanese all see the black cat as lucky.

In real life, a black cat named Oscar was unlucky enough to lose his back feet to a combine but lucky enough to have people who would fit him with prosthetics. How lucky or unlucky any animal is boiled down to perspective.

Cats Will Steal the Breath of a Baby

Baby and cat sleeping together on white sheet

Cats have no ability to do this. However, cats do like the smell of milk, something a baby's breath often smells of. A cat may get too close to a baby's face trying to find where the milk smell is coming from.

A fluffy cat so close to a baby's face can cause suffocation. The cat is not purposely trying to steal the baby's breath. That said, you should still not leave an animal alone with a baby or very small child.

Supervise their interaction to make sure neither is hurting the other. Keep cats out of the crib and off a sleeping baby.

They Work For The Devil

Portrait of British gray cat wearing a devil costume on white background

Well, who doesn't? Little joke there for anyone who's ever had a bad boss. No. A cat would probably treat any would-be master with the same contempt she does anyone who thinks they can boss her around.

This rumor got started in the Twelfth Century when the Church really started cracking down on heretics. The Albigensians were one such persecuted group. It was rumored that they worshipped Satan, who took the form of a black cat.

Before long, any woman with a black cat was accused of witchcraft. This soon extended to cats of all colors. For example, the First Witch in Shakespeare's Macbeth speaks of her two cats; one named Graymalkin (a name given to gray cats) and one described as brindled.

Whatever you believe, cats are far too independent to work for anyone.

They Caused The Black Death

Back view of black cat sitting on black background with face turned to the viewer

No. Cats didn't cause the plague of the mid-1300s, and the popular story that killing cats made it worse is a guess that historians still argue about.

The bubonic plague is caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis and spreads mainly through fleas from infected rodents (some researchers think human fleas and lice helped it spread too). Cats can actually catch plague themselves, and in the western United States infected cats have passed it to people, which is one more reason to keep up with flea prevention.

The Black Death killed somewhere between a third and half of Europe's population. It was caused by a germ, not by demons, witches or cats.

Cats can see in complete darkness

Not in complete darkness. Cats can see better in dim light than humans can, but not in total darkness. Cats do have something called a tapetum, which is an ultra reflective layer of tissue that reflects light back towards the retina.

This layer gives incoming light a second pass through the retina, and cats' eyes are also packed with rod cells that work in low light. That's why they manage well at dusk, but in a completely dark room they rely on their whiskers, hearing and nose instead. Read more: can cats see in the dark?

This is what makes cat eyes appear to glow in very dim light. Actually, it's more like a safety reflector.

Cats are nocturnal

Crepuscular would be the better word. Cats prefer to be active around dawn and dusk hours. It's not too bright, not too dark and the temperature is just right. This is why they're such great pets for people who are at work or school most of the day.

They'll just take a nice long nap while you're gone and be ready to play in the evening. Don't be surprised, though, if Kitty wakes you at the crack of dawn wanting to be fed.

All cats hate water

Let's revisit Shakespeare's Macbeth. In one scene, Lady Macbeth tauntingly compares her husband to “the poor cat i’ the adage”. The adage she refers to is “The cat loves fish, but does not like to wet her paws.” This is true for some cats.

Many of them. But hardly all. Part of the dislike is practical: wet fur is heavy, cold and slow to dry (more on why cats hate water). Some cats have an odd habit of drinking by using the paw as a sponge and licking the water off. And some cats actually love water!

A Maine Coon may sit in a bath tub and chirp until someone runs a bath for him. The Turkish Van is famous for liking a swim. Any cat near a pool needs supervision, though, because cats can drown if they can't climb out (see can cats swim?).

Island bred cats like the Manx and Japanese bobtail particularly have no qualms about getting their paws a little wet, particularly if it means getting fish.

Cats only purr when they are happy

This is where cats can be like people. It is assumed that if a person is smiling, they must be happy. Actually, many people smile because they want you to think they're happy or at least friendly.

Like with a person's smile, a purr could mean something other than happiness. Such as covering up guilt, (Now, how could you accuse cute little me of shredding your curtains?) fear, (I'm really nice! Please don't hurt me!) wanting something, (Look at this cute little kitty! Don't you just wanna snuggle him and stuff him with treats?) trying to comfort frightened kittens (Everything is fine, sweetie.) or self soothing while in immense pain. (Everything is fine…everything is fine…everything is fine….)

Cats are known to purr while in labor. This is akin to a woman with the mindset of “Wow! I can't wait to meet my baby! OH, HOLY %$#@ THAT HURTS!” People who smile for reasons other than happiness are often called Stepford Smilers after Ira Levin's novel The Stepford Wives. Is your cat a Stepford purrer? If a purring cat is also hiding, not eating or seems sore, call your vet rather than assuming she's content.

Cat Myths Debunked [Top 20] - Do They Really Have Nine Lives? 1

They Can Predict The Weather

Cats notice things we don't. Their hearing picks up distant thunder long before we do, and they seek out warm spots as soon as the temperature drops.

That may be where the idea comes from: a cat that hides before a storm has probably just heard it coming.

That said, they have no mystical connection to predicting let alone causing weather. Their sneezes are not connected to weather. (Though perhaps to pollen count.)

Baptizing a cat with mineral water will not end a drought. You will just have a wet and angry cat. Being mean to a cat will not bring rain to your funeral. (Be nice to cats anyway.)

My Cat Flicks Her Tail, She Must Be Happy

Ever read Alice's Adventures in Wonderland by Lewis Carroll? There's a section in the book where Alice meets the Cheshire Cat. The Cheshire Cat tells her “We're all mad here.” Alice asks the cat how he knows he's mad. The cat's explanation is “you see, a dog growls when it's angry, and wags its tail when it's pleased.

Now I growl when I'm pleased, and wag my tail when I'm angry. Therefore I'm mad.” Alice comments that she calls the rumbling sound of a happy cat purring, but Cheshire doesn't seem to think it makes any difference and changed the subject to the Queen's croquet game.

Dogs wag their tails when happy, but body language is quite different for a cat (see why cats wag their tails). If she's wagging her tail she's probably feeling irritated or indecisive at the very least. A slight flick may just mean she's bored or running thin on patience. You may notice fighting cats lash their tails very sharply.

They’re Basically Living Urns For Human Souls

In some Buddhist sects of the ancient kingdoms of Burma and Siam it was believed that the souls of the holy would be transferred to a cat for safekeeping.

Before a coronation, a Siamese cat would be decked in gold so that the former king could watch his successor take the throne. Once the cat died, the holy soul was ready for Nirvana. (Not the grunge rock band.) It's a lovely legend, but a legend all the same.

Tabby cat names

Female Cats Should Give Birth before Being Spayed

Your cat does not really need kittens and neither do you. In fact, it's best to get her spayed before her first heat cycle in order to reap the full health benefits.

According to the Cornell Feline Health Center, spaying before 6 months of age cuts a cat's risk of mammary cancer by about 91%. It also prevents uterine infections and spares her repeated heat cycles. There are enough unwanted kittens in the world so please don't add more (here's what spaying a cat costs). Want your kids to learn about the “miracle” of birth? Get them a book.

Robie Harris and Michael Emberley have a series of age appropriate books that are highly recommended.

Cat Myths Debunked [Top 20] - Do They Really Have Nine Lives? 2

Are you planning to live in a bubble too? An indoor cat may be safer than an outdoor cat but viruses can still come into the house. Get your cat vaccinated.

If a Cat is Eating Grass, It Means She is Sick

Not usually. In a 2019 University of California, Davis survey of 1,021 cat owners, 71% had seen their cats eat grass, about 91% said their cats did not seem ill beforehand, and only about a quarter of the grass-eaters vomited afterward. The researchers think it's a habit inherited from wild ancestors that may help move hair and intestinal parasites through the gut.

Grass itself is fine (a pot of pet-safe cat grass is an easy indoor option), but many houseplants are not, and lilies can cause fatal kidney failure in cats. If your cat vomits often, stops eating or seems lethargic, see your vet rather than blaming the grass. More ideas: how to keep cats out of plants.

green grass cat Isolated on white background

Cats Are Cold and Aloof

This is a stereotype. It may have a small basis in truth: a cat wants to know if you are worthy of her company first. But a 2019 Oregon State University study found that about 64% of kittens showed a secure attachment to their caregivers, much like babies and dogs do.

Once a cat has decided someone is worth their company, they'll be the sweetest, cuddliest thing around. It's not so much that they're aloof, just particular. How much a cat has been handled as a kitten has much to do with their attitude towards people. A cat is more likely to attach themselves to people if they have more positive experiences with people growing up.

Will rubbing butter on a cat's paws help her find her way home?

cat footprint isolated on white

HA HA HA HA HA!!!! No. All you will have is a cat with butter on her paws. Good luck buttering your cat's paws to start with!

Even if she does sit still for such indignity, it will be likely so that she can lick the butter off the paw you just buttered. By the time you've got that fourth paw buttered, she's licked one paw clean and is starting on the next.

Incidentally, butter is very high in fat and isn't good for a cat to eat much of. The non-superstitious reasoning is that if a cat is brought to a new home, buttering her feet and letting her lick them will get her acclimated to the new place.

The real solution is going to take more patience and vigilance than that.

Cats Are Low-Maintenance

Pfft…who told you that? They need veterinary care, grooming, affection, attention, stimulation, food, water and a dozen or so other things.

Guess who cleans the litter box? Guess who trims their nails? Guess who turns on the laser pointer for them to chase? Look in the mirror.

Cats Need a Saucer of Milk

Kittens drink their mother's milk, but most cats lose much of their ability to digest lactose after weaning. Cow's milk can give an adult cat diarrhea, gas and an upset stomach, and cats don't need it: water and a complete cat food cover everything. A lick of plain yogurt or a cat-specific “milk” now and then is fine for most cats. See which dairy foods are safe in can cats eat dairy?

Pregnant Women Have to Give Up Their Cats

No. The worry is toxoplasmosis, a parasite infection that can harm an unborn baby and that cats can shed in their feces. But the CDC says pregnant women don't need to give up their cats. People more often catch it from undercooked meat or garden soil. Ask someone else to scoop the litter box every day (the parasite needs 1 to 5 days in the litter to become infectious), or wear disposable gloves and wash your hands well if you must do it yourself. Keep your cat indoors and don't feed it raw meat.

FAQs

 Are cats a sign of good luck?

Some people think that cats are a sign of good luck. Black cats are actually considered lucky in the UK and by sailors who like to have one on board. Actually, a cat of any color is good to have on a ship because they catch mice and other vermin.

In Japan, calicos are considered lucky, particularly in financial matters. Businesses will often put a maneki-neko near the entrance for luck.

The Korat cat of Thailand is said to bring prosperity and is often given as a wedding gift. In truth, all any “lucky charm”, living or otherwise, can do is give the owner a sense of confidence.

Will cats protect their owners?

Cats, unlike dogs, will not protect their owners in most cases and are more inclined to flee rather than fight when there's danger. However, a cat will protect what's theirs. There have been cases where cats whipped out the claws to protect their favorite people.

Cats are more sensitive to smells, sounds and slight movements that people might not notice. A cat might sense a gas leak or on coming earthquake before you can. The trouble is, they can't tell you what the problem is in words. If your cat is acting bizarre, she may be trying to warn you of some danger.

Can cats see different dimensions?

The existence of the universe having more than three dimensions (four if you count time) is very theoretical and strongly in the realm of science fiction. According to string theory, if different dimensions exist they are very small. Cats may have bizarre reactions, acting relaxed one moment and frightened the next.

Do recall that they have a stronger sense of hearing than you do. You may not hear a Rottweiler barking ten blocks away but your cat might and decided to find a hiding space before Killer finds him.

Are cats social animals?

Cats are social animals but there is a lot to be said about this. Do you want your cat to be social? While wild cats (save lions) prefer to live and hunt alone, house cats are meant for families. They depend on humans.

They tend to get along better with other cats if they've known them since they were young. They're not fond of sharing so make sure there are plenty of resources to go around. Show your cat affection and she will respond in kind, albeit on her terms.

Can a house cat kill a human?

A healthy house cat isn't going to kill an adult, but cats can still hurt people. Cat bites often get infected (see a doctor for any deep bite, or one that swells or turns red), scratches can spread cat scratch disease, and cat feces can carry Toxoplasma, so people with weak immune systems should let someone else scoop the litter. Keep your cat's vaccines up to date.

Cats hunt birds, mice and other small animals, not people. Domestication has made cats see people as a source of food and comfort, so a cat that bites or swats is usually scared, in pain or overstimulated.

Conclusion

Debunking cat myths is crucial for responsible cat ownership. These myths can lead to misunderstandings and potentially harm cats. By relying on accurate information and understanding their true needs, we can provide better care and build stronger bonds with our feline companions, ultimately ensuring their well-being and happiness.

Don't believe everything you've heard about cats. Of course, don't disbelieve all of it either. Some of these myths have a basis in fact, but many of them are simply grade A hokum.

Sources

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

5900 Balcones Dr Ste 5963
Austin, TX 78731-4298

DMCA.com Protection Status

Follow us:

Disclaimer

www.felineliving.net is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com. Amazon, the Amazon logo, AmazonSupply, and the AmazonSupply logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.