4 Best Hypoallergenic Cat Foods [2019 Buyer’s Guide & Reviews]

image of a feline eating from her bowl

There’s nothing more frustrating than seeing your kitty suffer from an allergy—and it turns out the food she’s eating is often the culprit.

Fortunately, if you know your feline struggles with a food sensitivity, you can usually manage it well by feeding her a hypoallergenic diet.

And here’s the two-part, million dollar question:

How can you tell if your cat has a food allergy—and if so, what’s the best type of food for her?

In this review, we’re going to talk about what cat food allergies are, how to tell if your little furball suffers from one, and which type of food will be the best for her to eat.

To help you choose the right product, we’ll also give you some insider tips on the top 4 brands we found in our research—based off price, quality of ingredients, effectiveness, and customer reviews.

Let’s dig in!

You love what you see? Purrfect! Rest assured that I put these products on the list specifically due to their genuine quality and not for other reasons.
I would just like to be transparent with you and inform you that FelineLiving may obtain a share of sales or other monetary compensation from the links on this page. I hope your furry friends will love these reviewed products and that it will spark joy in each pair of feline eyes!

Mary Nielsen ♥

A Review of the Top 4 Best Hypoallergenic Cat Foods

By this point, it hopefully makes sense why paying attention to your kitty’s food can often make a big difference in her allergy signs. Now comes the fun part:

Deciding which is the best hypoallergenic cat food for your animal—and your wallet!

We’ve looked at some of the most popular brands on the market. These four options have come out on top. In no particular order, let’s take a peek now:

  1. Merrick Limited Ingredient Diet Can Cat Food
  2. Instinct Original Grain Free Recipe Natural Wet Canned Cat Food Chicken
  3. Organix Organic Canned Cat Food Shredded Chicken & Chicken Liver
  4. Instinct Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free Recipe Natural Dry Cat Food by Nature’s Variety

1. Merrick Limited Ingredient Diet Can Cat Food

Merrick Limited Ingredient Diet cat food is grain-free and made with real chicken. As a single-source protein product, it’s free of fish (a type of protein that many cats are becoming allergic or intolerant to). This canned food is also free of potatoes and other common preservatives that can be problematic.

As an added bonus, this food is also rich in vitamins and healthy omega-3 fatty acids, which are excellent for your kitty’s skin and coat. It’s also free of carageenan, which some research shows is inflammatory.

Merrick Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free Chicken Canned Cat Food, 5 Oz., Case Of 24
  • Single-Source Animal Protein Recipes With #1 Ingredient Real Deboned Chicken
  • Simple Ingredient Panel For Cats With Food Sensitivities
  • Grain-Free Nutrition With No Gluten Ingredients For Easier Digestibility. Recipe Also Includes Omega...
  • Potato-Free And Fish-Free Recipe
  • Cooked In The Usa.

Last update on 2019-12-13 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

  • Pros: cooked in the USA, grain- and potato-free, vitamin and mineral rich; high crude protein content; cats like it
  • Cons: sometimes the moisture content and volume of food is lacking in these cans; some users have found mold in the cans
Crude Protein 8.0% min
Crude Fat 4.0% min
Crude Fiber 1.4% max
Moisture 78.0% max

2. Instinct Original Grain Free Recipe Natural Wet Canned Cat Food Chicken

Instinct Original Grain Free Recipe is tasty and delicious—according to cats anyway! The pate style texture is moisture and protein rich, and made with real chicken, turkey, and chicken liver protein…95% of the ingredients, to be exact. The other 5% comes from veggies, fruits, and healthy vitamins and fats.

This made in America product is free of grains, potatoes, corn, soy, weat, carrageenan, by-product, artifical colors, and preservatives. Even a few pet owners with older and chronically ill cats have found success with it.

Instinct Original Grain Free Real Chicken Recipe Natural Wet Canned Cat Food by Nature's Variety, 3...
  • GRAIN FREE CAT FOOD WITH CAGE FREE CHICKEN: Instinct Original is made with 95% chicken, turkey &...
  • CANNED CAT FOOD WITH NO FILLERS: Instinct Original wet cat food is high protein cat food. Made...
  • NATURAL CAT FOOD: Made from real meat & whole food ingredients, our grain free wet cat food is...
  • RAW INSPIRED WET CAT FOOD: Our canned cat food offers complete & balanced nutrition from real...
  • INSTINCT, THE RAW BRAND: We craft wet & dry cat food from real ingredients. Compare Instinct to Blue...

Last update on 2019-12-13 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

  • Pros: high quality chicken (cage-free), works well for managing allergies and other conditions, made in the USA
  • Cons: some cans reportedly found with maggots in it; picky cats may not adjust to it well; pricey
Crude Protein 11.0% min
Crude Fat 7.5% min
Crude Fiber 3.0% max
Moisture 78.0% max

3. Organix Organic Canned Cat Food Shredded Chicken & Chicken Liver

Chicken is a great quality meat for all cats, especially kitties with food allergies. This food—Organix Organic Canned Cat Food—contains free-range organic chicken…something most humans wouldn’t mind eating! It’s high nutrient density is rounded out with real ingredients like organic flaxseed, organic cranberries, and organic coconut flour.

Organix Shredded Chicken & Chicken Liver Recipe For Adult Cats, 5.5-Ounce Cans (Pack Of 24)
  • #1 Ingredient Is Organic, Free-Range Chicken
  • Made With A Nutrient-Packed Superfood Blend Featuring Organic Flaxseed, Organic Coconut Flour,...
  • No Artificial Preservatives, Added Growth Hormones Or Antibiotics
  • No Chemical Pesticides Or Synthetic Fertilizers
  • Cooked In An Organically Certified Usa Kitchen

Last update on 2019-12-13 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

  • Pros: high quality chicken meat and chicken liver, free of pesticides and synthetic chemcials, cooked in a certified organic manufacturer in the USA
  • Cons: contains egg protein (some cats may be allergic to this); some cats don’t seem to like the texture of this food, expensive
Crude Protein 9.0% min
Crude Fat 5.0% min
Crude Fiber 1.0% max
Moisture 78.0% max

4. Instinct Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free Recipe Natural Dry Cat Food by Nature’s Variety

For our final pick, we’ve singled out Instinct Limited Ingredient Diet dry cat food. While dry kibble generally has lower moisture content than canned food, many kitties do well with this style (and canned food can be an easy topper to add on if you have concerns), and it often is more cost-effective.

This product contains real rabbit as the protein source, and is free of grains, eggs, chicken, beef, sweet potato, artificial colors, wheat, soy, chickpeas, corn, and preservatives. Kibble is raw coated for an added nutrient boost—and appeal to even picky eaters.

Instinct Limited Ingredient Diet Grain Free Recipe with Real Rabbit Natural Dry Cat Food by Nature's...
  • GRAIN FREE CAT FOOD FOR CATS WITH SENSITIVITIES: Instinct Limited Ingredient cat food is made with 1...
  • NATURAL CAT FOOD WITH FARM RAISED RABBIT: Crafted for cats with food allergy, our Limited...
  • THE FIRST RAW COATED KIBBLE: Instinct Limited Ingredient dry cat food is cat food where every piece...
  • POWER OF RAW INGREDIENTS: Our cat food is made with the pure, real nutrition of raw. Raw is natural,...
  • OUR BEST CAT FOOD FOR ALLERGIES: We craft dry & wet cat food from real ingredients. Compare Instinct...

Last update on 2019-12-13 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

  • Pros: cost-effective, good option for cats allergic to chicken, eggs, beef, and potatoes (it happens!)
  • Cons: recent formula change doesn’t seem to be as effective for many cats; food can stain the carpet if vomited up
Crude Protein 7.0% min
Crude Fat 2.5% min
Crude Fiber 2.0% max
Moisture 82.0% max

What Are Cat Food Allergies?

According to some research, a food allergy is the third most common type of allergy seen in cats—topped only by flea bite allergies and inhalant allergies (from airborne particles like pollen and chemicals).

A cat food allergy occurs when a specific substance in your feline’s diet stimulates an over-the-top immune system response. When the triggering substance (subsequently called an allergen) gets into your cat’s body, immune cells in her digestive tract produce antibodies. These antibodies signal other immune cells to attack the “threatening” allergen, even if the allergen isn’t particularly harmful or noxious to most other animals.

Indeed, your cat may develop an allergy to a substance that never bothered them in the past!

Aside from creating a variety of uncomfortable symptoms (which we’ll discuss shortly), a food allergy can also damage your kitty’s intestinal tract, making it “leaky.” Over time, this can lead to a variety of problems, including decreased nutrient absorption and even a weakened immune system!

It’s not entirely clear what causes an allergy to develop in the first place, but most cats who end up getting one will develop it between age 2 and 6. They appear to affect male cats and female cats equally, as well as fixed and unfixed animals. Certain breeds may be at a greater risk for developing them, but pretty much any breed can be affected.

So, what kinds of food allergens are the culprits? The most common ones include gluten (a protein found in wheat and other grains), corn, dairy, soy, artificial preservatives (including fillers and coloring), and meat by-products.

Notice something interesting? Most of these ingredients are found in popular commercial brand cat foods!

Symptoms of a Food Allergy in Cats

image of a kitty suffering from food allergy

Here’s a hot tip from veterinarians:

If your cat has chronic yeast infections or year-round skin problems which seem to respond to medication but come back as soon as the medication runs out, then her issues probably stem from the food she’s eating!

Your vet will probably also advise you to look out for other common signs of a food allergy:

  • Excessive scratching and itching
  • Flaky, dry, red, inflamed, and irritated skin
  • Dull looking coat
  • Foul smelling skin and coat
  • Sneezing, coughing, wheezing, and other respiratory signs (she may “snore” because her throat is inflamed)
  • Runny eyes and nose
  • Frequent chewing  at her paws
  • Fatigue, lethargy, and low energy

Now, you might be wondering what the difference is between a food allergy and a food intolerance (or if there even is a difference). In cats, at least, the main difference is that 1) a food allergy stimulates a specific immune system reactivity, and 2) the main symptoms are generally related to the skin, whereas a food intolerance tends to lead to gastrointestinal issues like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea.

That said, the best cat food for allergies is often good for cats with food intolerances, too, since they’re generally made with higher quality ingredients. So if you notice any of the above signs, it may be worth looking into switching up your pet’s food.

Identifying and Treating Your Cat’s Allergy

Image of a kitty scratching herself

So, let’s say your cat does scratch a lot and has itchy irritated skin. She get’s ear infections a lot and snores in her sleep. Sure, it may sound cute—but it could indicate a big problem!

Now comes the challenge of figuring out what’s causing her food allergy. Is it dairy? Soy? Gluten? Something else? Sometimes protein in eggs, fish, or even beef can cause a food allergy in cats.

Unfortunately, diagnosing a food allergy in cats can be a little tricky. There isn’t really a specific test to help you determine what’s causing it. A lot of it comes down to some trial and error—removing certain foods from her diet and seeing how it affects her. A formal way to do this is called an elimination diet—something your vet can help you do.

So, what’s the best cat food for skin allergies that you should replace her current food with? Your best bet is to go for a kind called hypoallergenic.

What is Hypoallergenic Cat Food?

Hypoallergenic cat food has been specifically formulated to be free of common allergens. By default, it’s usually made with very high quality ingredients (like real meat, healthy fats, and low carbohydrates like vegetables and fruits) and free of the low-quality ingredients like fillers and artificial colors.

Many types of hypoallergenic or “limited ingredient” foods are also minimally processed, meaning they haven’t been made with a lot of heat or other processes which can affect the food quality.

Now, it’s important to realize that one type of hypoallergenic food may work well for one cat—but not for your cat. It really all depends on what your animal’s specific intolerances or allergeies are.

That said, the obvious benefit of giving your pet the right type of hypoallergenic cat food for her is that it can reduce or even eliminate her food allergy symptoms. Good hypoallergenic food is also usually nutrient rich and can even restore her gut health, too.

And while hypoallergenic food is often more expensive than regular food, most pet owners with sensitive kitties find that the extra price is well worth the investment.

One more thing:

In addition to trying out a hypoallergenic food (we’ll get into the reviews shortly), there are a few other things you can do which can help your kitty living with a food allergy:

  • Ask your vet about probiotics, essential fatty acids, digestive enzymes, and other supplements which may enhance her overall health.
  • Ask your vet about medications (whether oral or topical)—your kitty may need some to help her irritated skin and other inflamed tissue heal.
  • Make sure you consider the types of treats you’re giving her! Many popular kitty treats are full of the same kind of additives, fillers, and other allergens that pose a lot of problems for kitties. Dried or freeze dried meats and organ meat are usually a good pick.
  • Also, make sure that she gets plenty of water. Cats don’t have a strong thirst drive, since they evolved as carnivores and got most of their hydration from the moisture-rich meat they ate. But kitties need to be well-hydrated to make sure digestive motility (and other physiological processes) go smoothly. So, try putting her water dish away from her food dish (to mirror a cat’s instinct to keep it’s kill away from water sources) and select food that’s free of junk carbs (fortunately, pretty much all hypoallergenic cat foods are).

How Do I Change My Cat’s Diet?

image of a cat eating from her bowl

You know your kitty is sensitive to something in her food. You’ve gone through your choices and have selected a new product to try, hopeful that it’ll make a difference in her signs.

Now, how exactly do you transition her from her old food to her new food?

Here’s a hint:

Slowly!

Kitties with food allergies are already sensitive to their diet. But ALL cats do best with a gradual and measured transition from one food to another. After all, doing it too quickly can lead to serious gastrointestinal problems like bloating, gas, vomiting, constipation, and diarrhea…something you’re trying to FIX for her.

Here’s a general guideline to follow:

  • For about two to four days, mix about 25% of your little girl’s new food in with her old food.
  • For the next two to four days, mix about 50% of her new food in with 50% of her old food.
  • After about three or four days half and half, change the percentage to 75% new food and 25% old food.
  • Finally, you can then switch her to 100% new food.

As you’re doing this, pay close attention to how she’s responding to her new diet. If you have any concerns, just give your vet a call. He or she will be able to give you some more guidance on what to do.

What to Consider When Buying Hypoallergenic Cat Food

image of a tabby feline

Once you’ve determined that your kitty has a food allergy, it’s time to go over your purchasing options.

Hopefully, the above reviews will help kickstart the process for you!

In the meantime, there are a few other things to keep in mind which can help you make the right choice for your furball. The following three factors are among the most important ones to consider when preparing to bring home hypoallergenic food:

Is It Wet or Dry Cat Food?

Many cats with food allergies or intolerances are older and/or have failing health. For these creatures, chewing hard kibble can be tough on their teeth and hard to swallow.

Additionally, if you give your pet only dry food, she may be at risk for dehydration (since wet food obviously has more moisture in it). And all cats, especially those with intolerances, need to be well-hydrated to ensure their digestive system runs smoothly.

Then again, cats can be picky (we love ’em, but it’s true!). Certain textures of canned wet food may be unappealing. Also, you can’t really free-feed with wet food, or at least as easily as you can with dry food—and this may be something your kitty is already used to.

For this reason, think about all the individual factors about your kitty when deciding to go wet vs. dry. Many pet owners opt to do both—using a bit of wet food as a treat on top of their kibble. It’s really a matter of pet preference and need.

Protein Source

image of a raw lean meat protein

For many kitties, beef, eggs, and fish cause an allergic reaction. So even though your chosen cat food may be considered hypoallergenic, it still may not be well tolerated if it contains any of these protein sources.

In general, kitties do well with chicken, turkey, duck—you know, things their ancestors may have caught and ate back in the wild! For the best bang for your buck, you want to find a product that has REAL meat as the main ingredient (e.g., deboned chicken), and ideally only one or two protein sources.

Do you see chicken liver on the ingredients list? That’s probably fine, since organ meat is rich in vitamins and minerals.

image of a Pinterest pin

Like it? Pin It!

Are There Any Common Ingredients to Avoid?

Unfortunately, the vast majority of commercial cat food products are loaded with bad ingredients.

As we’ve seen, hypoallergenic brands have been specially formulated to minimize the risk of allergy or intolerance…but sometimes, even “limited ingredient” foods can still contain ingredients which may prove problematic for your little one.

While your kitty’s specific tolerances are unique to her, the following ingredients are commonly:

  • Grains: (including wheat, barley, rice, corn)
  • Meat by-products: meat by-products are not high quality protein and can be hard to digest. Avoid these at all costs!
  • Dairy: a major allergen for many kitties. Avoid food and treats with cheese, milk, or any other dairy source.
  • Artificial colors, sweeteners, and preservatives: cats can’t even really taste sweetness, so we’re not sure why manufacturers bother trying to sweeten their food! That said, many companies use colors, sweeteners, preservatives in their foods to improve texture and taste, prolong shelf-life, and heck—even cut production costs. But these chemicals can disrupt health and exacerbate allergies, so try to avoid them as much as possible. They include things like sorbitol, sucrose, sugar, corn syrup, propylene glycol, BHA, BHT, TBHQ, ethoxyquin, propyl gallate, benzoic acid, sodium benzoate, potassium benzoate, sodium nitrate, and sodium nitrite.
  • Seafood: as mentioned, fish is often problematic for some cats. One reason is because it can trigger a thiamine deficiency if consumed raw and to access (the symptoms of thiamine deficiency include loss of appetite, seizures, or even death in severe cases!). Fish is also one of the top food allergy triggers for felines (the others being beef and dairy). When looking at the ingredients list, keep in mind that fish oil as well as fish protein may trigger a reaction if your kitty has a seafood allergy.

Conclusion

A hypoallergenic cat food may be the best choice for your animal if she has a food allergy or even just a food intolerance. It can relieve or eliminate her uncomfortable symptoms including skin irritation and improve her overall health—and in many cases, you don’t even need to put her on any special medications.

In fact, many cat parents prefer to give their pets hypoallergenic food even if they don’t have a specific allergy or intolerance. Why? Because this kind of food is usually nutrient dense and made with better quality ingredients overall. The extra price is well worth it, as far as many pet owners are concerned.

At the end of the day, you just want what’s best for your animal—that much is obvious. So start taking a closer look at the ingredients list of your animal’s food…there could be something there that your little feline could do without.

Resources:

  • December 29, 2018
Mary Nielsen
 

A huge animal lover, born and raised around dogs, cats, chickens... Self-educated pet care nerd. Currently parent of three adopted cats and one small mutt. Animal adoption advocate. Loves a good book (about animals) and playing the piano.